Ratings scale: 10 (The Best) thru 1 (The Worst).
Click the
category names for more information.
Rate
this restaurant's features.
Select a rating from each
category to the left, then click
submit. You must submit a rating
for each category. You may only vote
on each restaurant one time, so please select
your ratings carefully.
New owners. The quality of food went down and the prices went up.
Atmosphere
Nice atmosphere. Same as it was. It can get a little noisy.
Service
Service is OK. Pub style.
Value
Not worth the trip. Prices went up with the new ownership. They now charge for take-out. Both times I took out, they got the order wrong and I had to go back.
Overall
Overall, I’m sorry to say I will not go back. I'm very unhappy that we have lost a neighborhood favorite. It’s too bad when new owners take over and ruin a good thing.
Manny Man
1/6/2009
Food
This place used to be good until the ownership changed hands recently. I have been a local for a couple of years now and I never had a complaint before. I actually used to suggest going there for a meal. Now…stay away. The new owner has “cheaped out” on quality and quantity. The steak and eggs brunch used to be great with a nice thick piece of juicy steak with actual home fries and corn bread with eggs done to perfection. Now it's a small rubbery piece of skirt steak that looks more like chop meat and a cold sunny side up when I ask for over medium with a side of fried mashed potatoes.
When I asked to see the manager I got some stressed out head chef with an attitude. The salads used to be huge and delicious where now they’re small and expensive. The peddler has the best bartenders. I love them all but my meals have moved elsewhere. P.S. I also witnessed some patrons that complained about raw ground beef at the bottom of their nachos.
Atmosphere
n/c
Service
n/c
Value
n/c
Overall
n/c
steel
11/22/2007
Food
Wings great. 9
Atmosphere
Pub style. OK.
Service
Service below par. The bar in particular has the rudest and least attentive bartenders on Long Island! They are curt, impolite, unfriendly and have to be hit over the head to get their attention. Such a shame as the place itself is pretty cool but the bartenders make you feel so unwelcome that you have to find other reasons to go there that make you overlook this.
Value
n/c
Overall
n/c
maataa
1/9/2005
Food
Excellent arrays of specials accompanies an already abundant number of menu offerings. Special requests for prep were honored.
Atmosphere
Fun, lively atmosphere. The bar area is continually busy, but dinner seating is at a distance.
Service
An amazing, knowledgable, friendly staff that makes you feel right at home!
Value
Excellent.
Overall
Looking forward to a return visit. Will be a regular at the Peddler!
Website: N/A
Email: N/A
View Map: 
- Checked reviews indicate featured reviews.
